spammers and netmagazines.com?
In December of 2003 I bought a gift magazine subscription for a friend
through netmagazines.com. Expecting the worst, I used a unique
one-time email address generated explicitly for that transaction. I
have not received anything through that account over the past two
years other than the renewal notice and similar magazine offers. I expect these
> We do not distribute, sell, or rent your name or personal information to any third party, and will never do so without your permission. This includes any e-mail addresses or mailing addresses that you provide. When you place an order, your mailing address is only transmitted to the publisher or respective fulfillment house for the publication.
> From time to time, we will send updates about NetMagazines.com, such as special offers, updates or new titles. At time any time, you may express your desire not to receive these mailings, either by sending us e-mail or following the remove instructions included in every mailing we send.
However, I noticed that starting on July 1, 2005, I had spam for that
single use account. I can suggest several possibilities that might explain this:
* netmagazines.com and NetVision Associates, Inc. violated its
address to spammers.
* netmagazines.com and NetVision Associates, Inc. shared my email
address with an employee, associate or affiliate who themselves is a spammer or
distributed it to spammers.
* one of the publishing houses that netmagazines.com and NetVision Associates, Inc. work with
allowed my email address to be distributed to spammers.
* netmagazines.com and NetVision Associates, Inc. had its web site
security compromised and my email address was stolen and used by
* an internal host used by netmagazines.com or NetVision
Associates, Inc. was compromised and my email address was stolen
and used by spammers.
* a mail gateway or intermediary host between my mail exchangers
and the hosts of netmagazines.com or NetVision Associates, Inc.
was compromised and my email address was plucked out and used
* an incredibly unlikely combination of account, non-alphanumeric
separator and unique identifier at my domain was randomly used by spammers
and they got lucky.
I do not suggest that netmagazines.com or NetVision Associates,
Inc. is itself engaging in spamming or supporting spammers and I have no idea how
my email address came to be used by spammers.
However, given that even [United Airlines](http://www.lonsteins.com/archives/2004/01/30/united-airlines-sells-lists-to-spammers/) failed to protect a similar unique one-time email address,
I am unsurprised that a smaller organization also failed to protect
an email address from abuse.